idc why you like floyd, you just made it seem like wwh and animals werent concept albums o i made the correction. I like Waters lyrics and concepts as well, but i think the music is overall better on the other 2 and Darkside of the moon, I love the wall, i spent $250 a ticket to get floor seats coming up next month, I just think Floyds best work is when they werre all working well together.
WakeOfAshesPosts: 21,665destroyer of motherfuckers
The Wall
y u mad doe? u seem upset?
Im probably on edge because of shit at work... my bad. didnt mean to come off grumpy.
Yeah I love all of waters concept albums from The Dark Side of the Moon to Amused to death. This excludes Momentary lapse of reason (awful album) and Division bell (this album is okay). Although not a concept I really like Meddle.
why would you list DSOTM over WYWH... Being someone who loves Gilmours guitars, I'd have thought WYWH would come in before DSOTM
I just love that entire album. I dont know its just my opinion. I grew up on that album, its the first one I ever heard, it will never get old to me. I love wywh too, i just love darkside.
where does Momentary Lapse of Reason rank on your list?
WakeOfAshesPosts: 21,665destroyer of motherfuckers
The Wall
The thing I love about the Final Cut is some of the Lyrics.
"I HELD the BLADE in trembling hands prepared to make it BUT................ Just then the phone rang, I never had the nerve to make the final CUT."
You know the Final Cut is an continuation of the Wall... It's a concept that can be thought of as Pink's dealing with the world outside the wall. It's very personal and very raw. Very antiwar and roger's feelings about his dad. Anyone who loves the wall should naturally love the final cut.
I like all their albums like I said, even amlor just for the instrumental work, theres some nasty riffs and solos in there. Learning to fly kicks ass...
WakeOfAshesPosts: 21,665destroyer of motherfuckers
The Wall
yeah learning to fly is a great song, but one great song doesnt make an album. Especially if the rest of the album is... welll... that. Yeah I pointed to the whole album. Every other song on Momentary lapse of reason is complete garbage.
WakeOfAshesPosts: 21,665destroyer of motherfuckers
The Wall
I like all their albums like I said, even amlor just for the instrumental work, theres some nasty riffs and solos in there. Learning to fly kicks ass...
yeah I like almost all albums with the name Pink Floyd... Momentary Lapse of Reason being dead last as the only song I'd listen to from there was Learning to Fly.
It's funny - I have this good friend who once said to me "I can't stand Pink Floyd and don't know why anyone would like that garbage.... However they did make one good album that I love. Momentary lapse of reason"
I wish you would look at it as a different band rather then like oh Roger isnt there cause the album isnt as bad as you make it seem, you said before it was the worst album you ever heard, i mean cmon. I just think you hold anomosity they booted him out the band, but even Roger admitted he was being a Nazi back in the days... I mean these guys were all in the band and all had a hand in writing all the albums up to Animals, then Roger just took over and didnt want to hear shit from anyone. I dont think thats fair, it wasnt his band they all started it along with sid. Like I said I think their best work is when they were all working well together. But I think if you looked at AMLOR in a different light instead of just Roger isnt there, you would have a higher opinion of it, it isnt close to the best floyd album, but it doesnt suck.
Know what surprises me the most and is strangely odd? On a site where the music popularity is predominately metal, me you and Catz are like the only ones who really love FLoyd. Thats strange to me cause most metal fans, bands, producers, artists, ect... love FLoyd. I mean they are such an inspiration to the metal scene. Its surprising that so many people are liek meh, I dont get it. The first time I mentioned Floyd on here and got a negative responce, I thought niggas was trolling, lol... <_>
WakeOfAshesPosts: 21,665destroyer of motherfuckers
The Wall
I don't really look at it as "Roger isnt there so it sucks". Division Bell for example... I actually like the album quit a bit. It sounds much more Pink Floyd then MLOR. Although I believe they paid people to come in and help them write a pink Floyd sounding album, but the album is solid and I enjoy it from time to time.
WakeOfAshesPosts: 21,665destroyer of motherfuckers
edited June 2012
The Wall
btw - I was wondering where Bianca was today... I posted for like 4-5 hours and not one of my posts was marked Troll. If im being honest, I was getting a little concerned. I thought perhaps she might have taken a trip to the beach, and was mistakenly confused for a beached whale and thrown back in ocean. That would have been sad.... kinda.
Comments
idc why you like floyd, you just made it seem like wwh and animals werent concept albums o i made the correction. I like Waters lyrics and concepts as well, but i think the music is overall better on the other 2 and Darkside of the moon, I love the wall, i spent $250 a ticket to get floor seats coming up next month, I just think Floyds best work is when they werre all working well together.
Yeah I love all of waters concept albums from The Dark Side of the Moon to Amused to death. This excludes Momentary lapse of reason (awful album) and Division bell (this album is okay). Although not a concept I really like Meddle.
The Wall
The Final Cut
Wish you were Here
Animals
Dark Side of the Moon
Meddle.
Meddle
Dark Side of the Moon
Wish you were Here
The Wall
The Final Cut
"I HELD the BLADE in trembling hands prepared to make it BUT................ Just then the phone rang, I never had the nerve to make the final CUT."
You know the Final Cut is an continuation of the Wall... It's a concept that can be thought of as Pink's dealing with the world outside the wall. It's very personal and very raw. Very antiwar and roger's feelings about his dad. Anyone who loves the wall should naturally love the final cut.
It's funny - I have this good friend who once said to me "I can't stand Pink Floyd and don't know why anyone would like that garbage.... However they did make one good album that I love. Momentary lapse of reason"
I just started laughing. He was dead serious.
I wish you would look at it as a different band rather then like oh Roger isnt there cause the album isnt as bad as you make it seem, you said before it was the worst album you ever heard, i mean cmon. I just think you hold anomosity they booted him out the band, but even Roger admitted he was being a Nazi back in the days... I mean these guys were all in the band and all had a hand in writing all the albums up to Animals, then Roger just took over and didnt want to hear shit from anyone. I dont think thats fair, it wasnt his band they all started it along with sid. Like I said I think their best work is when they were all working well together. But I think if you looked at AMLOR in a different light instead of just Roger isnt there, you would have a higher opinion of it, it isnt close to the best floyd album, but it doesnt suck.