Implying music should be contained within a specific definition. You can have music without the ingredients of melody, rhythm, and harmony - or any of the three at all. You especially don't need structure.
The only people who regularly rep straight porno/goregrind and that stuff is that pscicosis dude. That stuff is pretty bad, I'll agree with you, but it's still music. Actual grindcore is still just as valid a form as music as other Core stuff though. Actual grindcore groups have some structure to the music, it's just really fast, short and to the point. Just because it might be difficult to discern it due to shitty recordings or fast, kind of sloppy playing doesn't make it any less legit. Personally, I'd rather listen to fast spurts of intense music than overdrawn breakdown filled deathcore.
Lol that shit ain't music, plain and simple.
It's quite literally just extremely fast jam sessions recorded. There's absolutely no structure, rhythm, or melody. You know, the 3 main ingredients that make music, music...
Still gonna say you're wrong. There's definitely rhythmic and structural elements. They're playing in time and there's still an element of "this riff for 4 measures, then riff b for 4, then we're down". And music doesn't really need melody. There's such a thing as post-tonal and atonal music. Also, music that's completely percussive is still music, right?
The only people who regularly rep straight porno/goregrind and that stuff is that pscicosis dude. That stuff is pretty bad, I'll agree with you, but it's still music. Actual grindcore is still just as valid a form as music as other Core stuff though. Actual grindcore groups have some structure to the music, it's just really fast, short and to the point. Just because it might be difficult to discern it due to shitty recordings or fast, kind of sloppy playing doesn't make it any less legit. Personally, I'd rather listen to fast spurts of intense music than overdrawn breakdown filled deathcore.
Lol that shit ain't music, plain and simple.
It's quite literally just extremely fast jam sessions recorded. There's absolutely no structure, rhythm, or melody. You know, the 3 main ingredients that make music, music...
If you dont think grind bands have structure or rhythm then you are absolutely fucking retarded
The only people who regularly rep straight porno/goregrind and that stuff is that pscicosis dude. That stuff is pretty bad, I'll agree with you, but it's still music. Actual grindcore is still just as valid a form as music as other Core stuff though. Actual grindcore groups have some structure to the music, it's just really fast, short and to the point. Just because it might be difficult to discern it due to shitty recordings or fast, kind of sloppy playing doesn't make it any less legit. Personally, I'd rather listen to fast spurts of intense music than overdrawn breakdown filled deathcore.
Lol that shit ain't music, plain and simple.
It's quite literally just extremely fast jam sessions recorded. There's absolutely no structure, rhythm, or melody. You know, the 3 main ingredients that make music, music...
Still gonna say you're wrong. There's definitely rhythmic and structural elements. They're playing in time and there's still an element of "this riff for 4 measures, then riff b for 4, then we're down". And music doesn't really need melody. There's such a thing as post-tonal and atonal music. Also, music that's completely percussive is still music, right?
Yes, but strictly percussive music, excluding drum solos, usually use drums tuned in a way that they can create melody.
The only people who regularly rep straight porno/goregrind and that stuff is that pscicosis dude. That stuff is pretty bad, I'll agree with you, but it's still music. Actual grindcore is still just as valid a form as music as other Core stuff though. Actual grindcore groups have some structure to the music, it's just really fast, short and to the point. Just because it might be difficult to discern it due to shitty recordings or fast, kind of sloppy playing doesn't make it any less legit. Personally, I'd rather listen to fast spurts of intense music than overdrawn breakdown filled deathcore.
Lol that shit ain't music, plain and simple.
It's quite literally just extremely fast jam sessions recorded. There's absolutely no structure, rhythm, or melody. You know, the 3 main ingredients that make music, music...
If you dont think grind bands have structure or rhythm then you are absolutely fucking retarded
Oh my bad, forgot blast beats for 50 seconds straight at 350 BPM counts as structure.
The only people who regularly rep straight porno/goregrind and that stuff is that pscicosis dude. That stuff is pretty bad, I'll agree with you, but it's still music. Actual grindcore is still just as valid a form as music as other Core stuff though. Actual grindcore groups have some structure to the music, it's just really fast, short and to the point. Just because it might be difficult to discern it due to shitty recordings or fast, kind of sloppy playing doesn't make it any less legit. Personally, I'd rather listen to fast spurts of intense music than overdrawn breakdown filled deathcore.
Lol that shit ain't music, plain and simple.
It's quite literally just extremely fast jam sessions recorded. There's absolutely no structure, rhythm, or melody. You know, the 3 main ingredients that make music, music...
Still gonna say you're wrong. There's definitely rhythmic and structural elements. They're playing in time and there's still an element of "this riff for 4 measures, then riff b for 4, then we're down". And music doesn't really need melody. There's such a thing as post-tonal and atonal music. Also, music that's completely percussive is still music, right?
Yes, but strictly percussive music, excluding drum solos, usually use drums tuned in a way that they can create melody.
It can, yes, but most percussive/tribal music feeds strictly off of rhythm.
The only people who regularly rep straight porno/goregrind and that stuff is that pscicosis dude. That stuff is pretty bad, I'll agree with you, but it's still music. Actual grindcore is still just as valid a form as music as other Core stuff though. Actual grindcore groups have some structure to the music, it's just really fast, short and to the point. Just because it might be difficult to discern it due to shitty recordings or fast, kind of sloppy playing doesn't make it any less legit. Personally, I'd rather listen to fast spurts of intense music than overdrawn breakdown filled deathcore.
Lol that shit ain't music, plain and simple.
It's quite literally just extremely fast jam sessions recorded. There's absolutely no structure, rhythm, or melody. You know, the 3 main ingredients that make music, music...
If you dont think grind bands have structure or rhythm then you are absolutely fucking retarded
Oh my bad, forgot blast beats for 50 seconds straight at 350 BPM counts as structure.
It does. It isn't structure that's typically seen or widely enjoyable, but theoretically it is still STRUCTURE. You're having issues with semantics again.
I know I used to say this to the point of mockery, but music is an art form and all art is subjective. It's completely experiential. This is why FaceFuck is wrong about completely electronic music not being music, and why you're wrong about grind.
Somebody could fart into a microphone and it could theoretically be music if it were organized in some fashion.
Comments
Yes, but strictly percussive music, excluding drum solos, usually use drums tuned in a way that they can create melody.
Oh my bad, forgot blast beats for 50 seconds straight at 350 BPM counts as structure.
"If you don't like it well then you're just a..... CUNT!"
So amazing ahahaha
A: That wasn't on TIAHBMISITIAHLKIAS.
B: I love how you ain't got shit to say sonically. Simply attacking lyrics.
I know I used to say this to the point of mockery, but music is an art form and all art is subjective. It's completely experiential. This is why FaceFuck is wrong about completely electronic music not being music, and why you're wrong about grind.
Somebody could fart into a microphone and it could theoretically be music if it were organized in some fashion.