The doors Floyd Log Mrh (until their last cd) Shadows fall Soulfly Nin I'm sure most of you won't agree with most of my list
I dont think I'd say a single band on your list in consistent. here are the first two reasons why I disagree with your list (yet still like these two bands)
Floyd - A Momentary Lapse of Reason - AWEFUL LOG - Wrath
I liked wrath and I think mlor was ok but when you have as many albums as they do at least one will be not as great. I still don't think they have ever made a bad album, it even had on the turning away on it so wasn't all bad.
wrath was a solid effort from a band that i really believe at the time was being pushed to make more mainstream friendly business from there label....i can't wait to get a good copy of resolution...what iv heard rocks
WakeOfAshesPosts: 21,665destroyer of motherfuckers
The doors Floyd Log Mrh (until their last cd) Shadows fall Soulfly Nin I'm sure most of you won't agree with most of my list
I dont think I'd say a single band on your list in consistent. here are the first two reasons why I disagree with your list (yet still like these two bands)
Floyd - A Momentary Lapse of Reason - AWEFUL LOG - Wrath
I liked wrath and I think mlor was ok but when you have as many albums as they do at least one will be not as great. I still don't think they have ever made a bad album, it even had on the turning away on it so wasn't all bad.
Im one of the biggest Floyd fans around... and that album was complete garbage. However I hardly even consider it a floyd album. Floyd was pretty much Roger Waters. Any album he took the lead role in creating is fucking gold. Everything else is almost crap. A Momentary Lapse of Reason is close to being the shittist album ever made. Outside of Learning to Fly, I could shit out sounds that sound better then the rest of that album.
The doors Floyd Log Mrh (until their last cd) Shadows fall Soulfly Nin I'm sure most of you won't agree with most of my list
I dont think I'd say a single band on your list in consistent. here are the first two reasons why I disagree with your list (yet still like these two bands)
Floyd - A Momentary Lapse of Reason - AWEFUL LOG - Wrath
I liked wrath and I think mlor was ok but when you have as many albums as they do at least one will be not as great. I still don't think they have ever made a bad album, it even had on the turning away on it so wasn't all bad.
Im one of the biggest Floyd fans around... and that album was complete garbage. However I hardly even consider it a floyd album. Floyd was pretty much Roger Waters. Any album he took the lead role in creating is fucking gold. Everything else is almost crap. A Momentary Lapse of Reason is close to being the shittist album ever made. Outside of Learning to Fly, I could shit out sounds that sound better then the rest of that album.
That's why I say it wasn't bad learning to fly and on the turning away are two classic so it wasn't that bad. Just my opinion. I think Gilmore and waters together make great music without either one it's not as good. The lyrics and guitar compliment each other like nobody else can accomplish. I actually take gilmores side, I couldn't work with that arrogant dickhead either.
I love NIN and can say they are not consistent. Doesn't mean any of Trent Reznor's work is bad, but there's an obvious difference in his most of his work over the past 20 years. Especially when you compare "With Teeth" and "Year Zero" to his drug addiction years.
I was going to put NIN as well, but then I remembered about Year Zero. Which wasn't a terrible album by any means, but definitely their weakest.
I love NIN and can say they are not consistent. Doesn't mean any of Trent Reznor's work is bad, but there's an obvious difference in his most of his work over the past 20 years. Especially when you compare "With Teeth" and "Year Zero" to his drug addiction years.
I didn't like with teeth till I saw it live then I understood what he heard while making it.year zero is my least favorite by far but I still think it's better than a lot of CDs out there.
Comments
devidriver sux
chimira sux
If you could just consider Pantera the band starting at cowboys then they would easily make the list.