This argument is getting ridiculous, theyre both great, 1 has 3 rings, the other has 1. One was supposed to win rings, the other was a 6th round pick who turned out to be a hall of fame QB. Without Brady and Manning those 2 teams aint shit and would suck, where as teams like the Steelers, Jets, Ravens could put anyone at QB and would still be good. And the Pats and Colts both have had great coaching too. They're # 1 and 2 in the NFL.
marvin harrison and reggie wayne are both starts because of manning.....sure harrison would have been a good wide out but manning made him a HOF....brady is awesome and a michigan player...i respect them both a lot...and think they are equally good players
I found this list some douche bag made before the start of the season rating the QB's. I think they can switch 2 & 3(although after last year i can see why they put brees 2) and I agree Manning or Brady 1 & 2, and Brees and Rodgers 3 & 4, but after 4, the list is a complete failure.......
drinkwine732Posts: 20,418destroyer of motherfuckers
Eli Manning should be nowhere near a top 10 list. Before you make the remark that rings matter, Eli shouldn't even have his ring, in fact, David Tyree should have two rings both his own and Manning's, as well as that Super Bowl MVP. Eli Manning is in the bottom 15 of QBs in the league, and is the reason why the Giants aren't the best team in the game by far.
My list is based on this year, although I agree with you about the superbowl they won, the Giants D was terrific, Eli's having a pretty good year, he's 4th in the league in TD passes and has the Giants as the number 1 seed in the NFC through half the season. They have no superstars on Offense, so he must be doing something right.
and the Giants have a great D. Theyre a scary team to have in my teams division. Eli's not in the bottom half of the NFl in QBs though. Theyre the #1 seed in the NFC and he's in the top 5 in TD passes so far this year. He's not great or HoF or anything like that, but he's good.
didnt think of rivers, but yooz are right, take out flacco, put in rivers at 10.
huh? try 1
cmon man? you think rivers is the best qb in the league? I'm not talking just stats, i'm talking if you could pick 1 qb to start a team who would it be? for me, brady
Comments
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/425110-the-top-10-quarterbacks-for-the-2010-nfl-season#page/1
1. Brady
2. Manning
3. Brees
4. Rodgers
5. Rapistburger
6. Ryan
7. Eli Manning
8. Cassel
9. Vick
10.Flacco
[-(
blue turbins
From Those Fishes - I Fingered An Old Bitch (i got Aids on my finger)
[-(
blue turbins
From Those Fishes - I Fingered An Old Bitch (i got Aids on my finger)
I'll take Peyton Manning.